GOODSOUND!GoodSound! "Ask Me" Archives

...to July 31, 2005

 

Used amp for B&Ws

July 29, 2005

I just bought a pair of B&W DM220i speakers, and the amplifier I'm using is a very old Sony TA-4670 V-FET. I'm considering an amp upgrade, but I have no idea what to buy. Because I'm a student, my budget is not very high, so I'm looking for a used amplifier. Can you give me some advice, or do I have to be more specific?

Borris van der Swaan

It would be helpful to know what you don't like about the Sony, what kind of room you have, your budget, and an idea of the music you like. I'm sure I could narrow it down more with those details. But as an all-around, can't lose recommendation I'd say something from NAD or Rotel would work well. Those brands have widespread availability, offer excellent value new or used, and are typically reliable, which is especially important if you're going to buy a used unit. They also make amps that can drive real-world speakers, and though I'm not familiar with the B&W models you cite, the brand has a reputation for craving solid amounts of power. With a later-model NAD or Rotel, you should hear an improvement over the old Sony.


Which sub for Magnepans?

July 27, 2005

I ordered my Magnepans yesterday (MMGW and MMGC). Now what to buy for the subwoofer? I like the Hsu STF-2 or Outlaw LFM-1. Please help.

Tony Becker

Both are similar products. The Outlaw has a larger woofer (12" vs. 10") and has a slightly beefier cabinet, so it may have a slight advantage with absolute output. It also has a bit more panache in the cosmetics department with the gloss top panel. But the Outlaw also carries a higher list price ($579 vs. $399). A better comparison to the Outlaw would be the Hsu STF-3 at $599. That unit compares favorably with the Outlaw across the board with its larger cabinet and woofer. Since Dr. Hsu helped with the design of the Outlaw subwoofer, the differences in performance would likely be negligible. Dr. Hsu knows subwoofers, and both products show the skill of this talented designer. Either way -- STF-3 or LFM-1 -- you can't lose.


Filling speakers with sand?

July 25, 2005

My speakers have a compartment that is supposed to be filled with sand. Can you tell me why this would be important? I don't mind doing it, but I fail to see the reasoning.

Mark

Sand can be used to damp or reduce cabinet resonance/vibration. Its effect is said to be much like having thicker cabinet panels -- only in this case you add the mass at home instead of the manufacturer building thicker, heavier cabinets at the factory. Lead shot can also be used in place of sand, in most instances. The only other reason I can think to add sand would be to keep steady a top-heavy speaker. Adding mass to the bass of a floorstanding speaker can accomplish this. As to whether the addition of sand will yield an audible improvement, there's only one way to find out -- head down to your local home-improvement store and load up some sand. They sell clean, filtered sand that will work perfectly for your intended use.


GOODSOUND!All Contents Copyright © 2005
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.